Surrendered income recorded in books treated as business income and taxed at normal rates, not under Section 115BBE.

Amounts offered during survey and later entered into the assessee's books were treated as business income where they were routed through regular business accounts; the governing principle applied was that surrender amounts recorded as business transactions, absent cogent material showing an independent source, attract normal rate taxation rather than a special-rate levy. The revenue's reliance on unexplained-income provisions was rejected for want of separate-source evidence, and the invocation of the special-rate provision was held unjustified, resulting in taxability at normal rates.

---

---

Issues: Whether the income amounts disclosed during survey and subsequently incorporated in the books and taxed at normal rates are exigible to tax under Section 115BBE of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (i.e., charged at the special rate) or are to be treated as business income taxable at normal rates.

Analysis: The Tribunal examined the facts that during survey the assessee's partner offered three amounts (unrecorded loans, excess cash, excess stock) as part of regular income, and those amounts were later included in the books of account by appropriate accounting entries. The Department invoked provisions of the section 69 family and charged tax under Section 115BBE. The Tribunal considered precedent where surrendered amounts routed through books and debited to business accounts were held to be business income. The Tribunal also noted that survey statements are not automatically conclusive and that revenue failed to produce cogent material showing a separate source of income distinct from the assessee's hospital business. The coordinate bench and High Court authorities relied upon indicate that where undisclosed items are recorded in books as business transactions and no independent evidence demonstrates they arise from other sources, they are to be treated as business income and taxed at normal rates rather than under Section 115BBE.

Conclusion: The invocation of Section 115BBE by the Revenue was not justified; the amounts disclosed during survey and incorporated in the books are to be treated as business income and taxable at normal rates. The appeal is allowed in favour of the assessee.

---