Permanent establishment under India-Ireland tax treaty not established where distributor acted as independent contractor and lacked contract authority.

A non-exclusive distributorship arrangement with an express independent-contractor clause did not create a permanent establishment in India under Article 5 of the India-Ireland Tax Treaty. The Indian distributor was not shown to habitually conclude contracts, hold stock, or act as the foreign enterprise's agent or legal representative, so no agency permanent establishment existed. The record also did not show any fixed place of business, or premises or personnel at the foreign enterprise's disposal in India, so no fixed place permanent establishment existed. Attribution of business income to India on that basis was therefore unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee had a fixed place permanent establishment or an agency permanent establishment in India under Article 5 of the India-Ireland Tax Treaty, and whether the resulting attribution of business income to India was sustainable.

Analysis: The distributorship agreement showed that the Indian entity was appointed as a non-exclusive distributor and licensee, the relationship between the parties was expressly that of independent contractors, and the distributor was not authorised to act as agent or legal representative of the assessee. The clauses relied upon by the tax authorities did not establish that the Indian entity habitually exercised authority to conclude contracts on behalf of the assessee, maintained stock on its behalf, or otherwise acted for and on behalf of the assessee. The record also did not establish that the assessee had any fixed place of business in India or that any premises or personnel were at its disposal so as to constitute a fixed place permanent establishment.

Conclusion: The assessee did not have either a fixed place permanent establishment or an agency permanent establishment in India, and the attribution made on that basis could not be sustained.

Ratio Decidendi: A non-exclusive distributorship arrangement, coupled with an express independent-contractor clause and the absence of evidence of authority to conclude contracts, disposal of premises, or business carried on through the foreign enterprise's own fixed place in India, does not establish a permanent establishment under Article 5.

---