Cash refund of Modvat credit on capital goods allowed when closure and surrender of registration made re-credit impossible.

Cash refund of Modvat credit on capital goods was treated as admissible where the assessee had closed its unit, surrendered Central Excise registration, and could no longer take re-credit. The Tribunal reasoned that factual inability to utilise the credit, arising from circumstances beyond the assessee's control, governed the claim, and that Rule 57S(3) of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 did not exclude refund in such a situation. The order allowing refund was upheld on the basis that the credit amount could be returned in cash when re-credit was no longer practically available.

---

---

Issues: Whether cash refund of the amount equivalent to Modvat credit on capital goods was admissible when the assessee had closed down its unit, surrendered Central Excise registration, and was therefore unable to take re-credit.

Analysis: The Tribunal noted that the assessee could not take re-credit after the Commissioner (Appeals) had allowed it because the unit had already been closed and registration had been cancelled. It relied on prior Tribunal decisions applying the principle that where credit on capital goods cannot be availed for reasons beyond the assessee's control, cash refund is permissible. Rule 57S(3) of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 was read as not excluding such a situation, and the factual inability to utilise credit was treated as the governing consideration.

Conclusion: Cash refund was held to be admissible and the order allowing refund was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: Where an assessee is unable to avail credit on capital goods because the unit has been closed and registration surrendered, the amount representing such credit may be refunded in cash notwithstanding the absence of an express provision for that precise factual situation.

---