Refund recredit follows reversal of illegal refund order; separate Section 11A notice is not a precondition.

When a refund order is held illegal and set aside in appeal, recredit of the refunded amount follows as a direct consequence, and a separate notice under Section 11A is not required before that recredit is directed. The refund had been treated as barred by limitation under Section 11B, so the appellate authority's reversal of the refund order necessarily restored the amount to the department. The wider scope of Section 11A was not examined because it did not arise on the facts as finally decided. The challenge to the recredit direction failed, and the appellate order was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether, after the refund order was found illegal and set aside in appeal, the appellate authority could direct the assessee to recredit the refunded amount without the original authority first issuing a notice under Section 11A.

Analysis: The refund had been granted on the basis of an approved classification list, and the appellate authority held that the refund was barred by limitation under Section 11B and was therefore illegal. Once the refund order itself was reversed, the direction requiring recredit of the amount already refunded was treated as the natural and necessary consequence of that reversal. The Court held that it was unnecessary to compel the department to initiate a further proceeding under Section 11A when the order granting refund had already been set aside in appeal. The Court also declined to go into the wider contention relating to the scope of Section 11A, since that issue did not arise on the facts as finally decided.

Conclusion: The direction to recredit the refunded amount was valid, and the assessee's challenge failed.

Final Conclusion: The appeal was dismissed, and the appellate authority's order restoring the refund amount to the department was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: When a refund order is held illegal and is set aside in appeal, recredit of the refunded amount follows as a direct consequence, and a separate notice under Section 11A is not a precondition for such recredit.

---