Corporate Guarantees to Subsidiaries Without Consideration Not Subject to Service Tax, Appeal Dismissed.

The appeal by the Department was dismissed, affirming the decision of the Commissioner (Appeals) that providing corporate guarantees to subsidiary units without any consideration does not attract service tax. The decision relied on precedents set by the SC and the Delhi HC, which established that such guarantees without consideration do not constitute a taxable service. The Department's argument was rejected, and the respondent's position, supported by a recent SC ruling, was upheld.

---

---

Issues involved:
The issue involves the consideration of whether providing corporate guarantees to subsidiary units for loans without any consideration is subject to levy of service tax.

Summary:

The appeal was filed by the Department challenging the order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) allowing the appeal by the respondent based on decisions of the Delhi High Court and the Supreme Court.

The main issue for consideration was whether providing corporate guarantees to subsidiary units for loans without any consideration is liable for service tax. The appellant provided such guarantees without any consideration, as noted in the show cause notice.

The Commissioner (Appeals) relied on the decisions of the Delhi High Court and the Supreme Court to allow the appeal by the respondent. The Department's authorized representative argued that the Additional Commissioner's order was justified.

The respondent's counsel referred to a recent Supreme Court decision where it was observed that providing corporate guarantees to group companies without consideration does not constitute a taxable service. Based on this and the decisions cited in the impugned order, the appeal was dismissed.

In conclusion, the appeal was dismissed in light of the decisions of the Supreme Court and the Commissioner (Appeals), as there was no demonstration that providing corporate guarantees without consideration would be a taxable service.

---