Tribunal rules no Service Tax on vehicle spare parts & handling charges if VAT paid

The tribunal held that no Service Tax can be charged on the value of spare parts used during servicing of vehicles or on handling charges included in the sale value of vehicles when VAT has been paid on these amounts. The tribunal upheld the impugned order, dismissing the revenue's appeal and disposing of the case.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Liability of Service Tax on Auto Mobile Parts used during servicing of motor vehicles at authorized service stations when VAT has been paid on such parts.
2. Liability of Service Tax on handling charges billed and collected by the respondent from their customer of the motor vehicle in the same bill of motor vehicle.

Issue 1: Liability of Service Tax on Auto Mobile Parts

The central question was whether Auto Mobile Parts used during the service of motor vehicles at authorized service stations are liable for Service Tax when VAT has already been paid on these parts. The appellant argued that as per the Board Circular No. 96/7/2007-ST dated 23.08.2007, service tax should be levied on the entire bill, including the value of spare parts used for servicing vehicles. The respondent countered that when the sale bill includes elements on which VAT has been paid, the same should not be subject to Service Tax. The tribunal referred to the Board Circular, which clarified that service tax is not leviable on transactions treated as the sale of goods and subjected to VAT. The tribunal concluded that if spare parts are sold and VAT is paid, no service tax can be demanded. This conclusion was supported by various judgments, including Ketan Motors Ltd Vs CCE and Automotive Manufacturers P. Ltd., which held that the value of spare parts and lubricants sold during the provision of authorized service station services would not attract Service Tax if VAT was paid on them.

Issue 2: Liability of Service Tax on Handling Charges

The second issue was whether handling charges billed and collected by the respondent from their customer in the same bill of the motor vehicle are liable to Service Tax. The respondent argued that handling charges are part of the sale value of the vehicle and VAT was paid on the total value, including handling charges. The tribunal found that handling charges are incidental to the sale of the vehicle and form part of the sale value on which VAT was paid. Therefore, no Service Tax can be charged on handling charges. This conclusion was supported by judgments such as Infinium Motors Guj. Pvt. Ltd Versus C.S.T. and Jivan Jyot Motors Pvt. Ltd Vs CCE, which held that when VAT is paid on the sale of goods, Service Tax cannot be demanded on any part of such value.

Conclusion:

The tribunal upheld the impugned order, concluding that no Service Tax can be charged on the value of spare parts sold during servicing of vehicles or on handling charges included in the sale value of vehicles when VAT has been paid on these amounts. The revenue's appeal was dismissed, and the CO was disposed of.

---