Club or association service tax requires proof of taxable service for consideration; demand and penalties failed here.

An incorporated or statutorily registered association was held not liable to service tax as a club or association for the relevant period unless the department proved that it rendered a taxable service for consideration. As the record did not establish that the amounts collected from members represented taxable consideration for any identifiable service, the demand failed and the consequential penalties could not be sustained. The assessee's status as a registered society also supported the conclusion that the receipts were outside the service tax net on the facts shown.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellant was liable to service tax under the category of Club or Association Service on amounts collected from members, and whether the demand and penalties could be sustained.

Analysis: The appellant was registered as a service tax assessee for Club or Association Services, but the record did not establish that the receipts represented taxable consideration for any identifiable service rendered to members. The Tribunal relied on the principle that incorporated clubs or associations, particularly those registered under a statute, were not within the service tax net for the relevant period, and noted the absence of evidence showing any taxable service. The appellant's status as a registered society also weighed against taxability under the category invoked.

Conclusion: The appellant was not liable to service tax under Club or Association Service, and the demand with consequential penalties could not be sustained. The finding is in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: An incorporated or statutorily registered association is not liable to service tax as a club or association for the relevant period unless the department proves that it rendered a taxable service for consideration.

---