Discharge in warrant cases requires unrebutted evidence that could justify conviction; mere association with an accused is insufficient.

In a warrant case, discharge under Section 245 CrPC depends on whether the evidence recorded under Section 244, if left unrebutted, would warrant conviction. Mere familiarity with an accused, or prior dealings in contraband, does not by itself create a live link to the present offence. Where the record contains no material sufficient to justify conviction if unrebutted, framing of charge is not warranted and the discharge order should stand. The ruling applies the threshold for discharge by requiring real incriminating material, not suspicion or association alone.

---

---

Issues: Whether the revisional court was justified in setting aside the discharge order and directing framing of charge, and whether the material on record disclosed a case against the petitioner sufficient to warrant his conviction if unrebutted.

Analysis: In a warrant case, the Magistrate, after taking evidence under Section 244 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, must decide discharge under Section 245 of the Code of Criminal Procedure on the basis of whether the evidence, if left unrebutted, would warrant conviction. The Court found that the fact that the petitioner knew one of the accused did not by itself connect him with the offence. The alleged earlier dealings in contraband and the surrounding materials were held insufficient to establish a live link with the present crime. On the record, no material was found that, if unrebutted, would justify conviction of the petitioner.

Conclusion: The order directing framing of charge was set aside and the petitioner's discharge was restored.

Final Conclusion: The petitioner succeeded because the record did not disclose sufficient material to justify framing of charge against him, and the original discharge order was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: For discharge in a warrant case, the evidence under Section 244 must disclose material which, if unrebutted, would warrant conviction; mere association with or knowledge of another accused is not enough to sustain a charge.

---