Clubbing of clearances for SSI exemption upheld where related units functioned under common control and shared resources.

Where closely related units operate under common management and financial control, with interlinked manufacturing activity, shared workers, premises, records and financial accommodation, their separate proprietary form may be disregarded and clearances clubbed for SSI exemption eligibility. On the facts, one unit lacked machinery, the manufacturing process was divided across units, and the arrangement was treated as not genuinely independent; the cited precedents were distinguished on facts. The clearances were therefore correctly clubbed, the units were denied separate entitlement to the Small Scale Industry exemption, and the orders confirming duty and denial of exemption were sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether the clearances of the four units were liable to be clubbed for determining eligibility to the Small Scale Industry exemption under Notification No. 8/2003-CE dated 01.03.2003.

Analysis: The record showed that the units were run by closely related family members, that the manufacturing process was divided between the units, that not all units had the full machinery required for manufacture, and that one unit had no machinery at all. The materials further showed common use of workers, shared premises and records, and mutual financial accommodation, indicating common management and financial control rather than truly independent manufacturing activity. On these facts, the separate existence of the units was treated as a mere arrangement, and the real nature of operations was found to justify clubbing of clearances. The cited precedents were held distinguishable on facts.

Conclusion: The clearances were correctly clubbed and the units were held not separately entitled to the SSI exemption.

Final Conclusion: The impugned orders confirming duty and denying separate exemption to the units were sustained, and the connected appeals failed.

Ratio Decidendi: Where closely related units operate under common management and financial control, with interlinked manufacturing activity and shared resources, their clearances may be clubbed for SSI exemption eligibility notwithstanding their separate proprietary form.

---