MRP valuation under Central Excise applies only where law requires retail sale price declaration on the package.

Packaged drinking water cleared to a customer for sale through snack bars was held not liable to valuation under Section 4A of the Central Excise Act because the packages were not shown to be required by the weight and measures law or any other law to bear retail sale price. The mere fact that the goods were specified was insufficient; absent a statutory obligation to declare MRP, valuation had to be under Section 4 on transaction value. The departmental theory of institutional sale and the demand based on MRP valuation therefore failed, and the consequential interest and penalty also could not survive.

---

---

Issues: Whether packaged drinking water cleared to a customer for sale through snack bars was liable to assessment under Section 4A of the Central Excise Act, 1944 on MRP basis, or under Section 4 on transaction value basis, and whether the consequent demand, interest, and penalty could survive.

Analysis: The determining factor for Section 4A is not merely that the goods are specified, but that the packages are required by the weight and measures law or any other law to bear retail sale price. On the facts, the goods were not shown to be meant for retail sale in the manner contemplated by the relevant rules, and the departmental reliance on the theory of institutional sale did not displace the legal requirement governing MRP-based valuation. The precedents relied upon by the assessee were applied to hold that where goods are not required to carry retail price and are not assessable as retail packages, Section 4A cannot be invoked. The Board circulars also supported valuation under Section 4 where no statutory obligation to declare retail sale price exists.

Conclusion: Assessment under Section 4A was held inapplicable and valuation under Section 4 was the correct basis. The demand, interest, and penalty could not stand.

Final Conclusion: The appellate order was set aside and the appeal was allowed, resulting in deletion of the duty demand and all consequential liabilities.

Ratio Decidendi: Section 4A applies only when the commodity is required by law to declare retail sale price on the package; absent that statutory requirement, valuation must be under Section 4.

---