Tribunal rules on Sales Tax liability under Section 145A, upholds Section 43B application

The Tribunal allowed the Revenue's appeal, dismissing the Assessee's cross-objection. It directed the AO to disallow the outstanding Sales Tax/Works Contract Tax liability to the extent included in the statement showing deviations from the valuation method under Section 145A. The Tribunal upheld that Section 43B applies even if the liability isn't in the Profit & Loss Account, as long as the deduction was effectively claimed.

---

---

Issues Involved:

1. Deletion of disallowance under Section 43B of the Income Tax Act.
2. Applicability of the Supreme Court judgment in Chowringhee Sales Bureau Pvt. Ltd. vs. CIT.
3. Treatment of unpaid Sales Tax/Works Contract Tax not routed through the Profit & Loss Account.
4. Consideration of input tax credit for setting off outstanding liabilities.

Detailed Analysis:

Issue 1: Deletion of Disallowance under Section 43B

The Revenue contested the CIT(A)'s decision to delete the disallowance of INR 3,78,15,218/- made by the Assessing Officer (AO) under Section 43B of the Act. The AO had added this amount to the total income of the Assessee, holding it as an outstanding liability for Sales Tax/Works Contract Tax that was not paid by the date of filing the return of income. The CIT(A) deleted this disallowance, accepting the Assessee's argument that since the liability was not routed through the Profit & Loss Account, no deduction was claimed, and hence Section 43B was not applicable. The Tribunal, however, overturned this decision, stating that the provisions of Section 43B are applicable even if the liability is not routed through the Profit & Loss Account, as long as the deduction has been effectively claimed.

Issue 2: Applicability of the Supreme Court Judgment in Chowringhee Sales Bureau Pvt. Ltd. vs. CIT

The Revenue argued that the judgment in Chowringhee Sales Bureau Pvt. Ltd. vs. CIT was applicable to the Assessee's case. The AO had reasoned that even if the Sales Tax/Works Contract Tax was not included in the Profit & Loss Account, it should be deemed to have been claimed as a deduction. The Tribunal noted that the CIT(A) had rejected this argument, but the Tribunal agreed with the AO, stating that the liability should be considered part of the turnover and thus subject to disallowance under Section 43B if unpaid by the filing date.

Issue 3: Treatment of Unpaid Sales Tax/Works Contract Tax Not Routed Through the Profit & Loss Account

The Assessee argued that since the Sales Tax/Works Contract Tax liability was not routed through the Profit & Loss Account, no deduction was claimed, and hence Section 43B should not apply. The Tribunal, however, held that the Assessee did not have the option to follow the exclusion method after the introduction of Section 145A of the Act, which mandates the inclusion method. Therefore, the Tribunal concluded that the provisions of Section 43B would be attracted even if the liability was not routed through the Profit & Loss Account.

Issue 4: Consideration of Input Tax Credit for Setting Off Outstanding Liabilities

The Assessee contended that it had sufficient input tax credit available as on the date of filing the return of income, which should be deemed as payment of the outstanding liability. The Tribunal rejected this argument, stating that mere availability of unutilized tax credit cannot be deemed as payment. The Tribunal emphasized that actual payment or actual set-off is required to avoid disallowance under Section 43B.

Conclusion:

The Tribunal allowed the Revenue's appeal and dismissed the Assessee's cross-objection. It directed the AO to disallow the outstanding Sales Tax/Works Contract Tax liability to the extent it is included in the statement showing deviations from the method of valuation prescribed under Section 145A of the Act. The Tribunal upheld the AO's view that the provisions of Section 43B are applicable even if the liability is not routed through the Profit & Loss Account, provided the deduction has been effectively claimed.

---