Tax appellate jurisdiction allows consideration of grounds raised at hearing and remand for fresh assessment when further enquiry is needed.

A tax appellate authority is not confined to the exact grounds in the memorandum of appeal and may consider additional grounds urged during hearing if they relate to the controversy and require examination of accounts and documents. The Tribunal may, within its appellate jurisdiction, set aside the assessment and remand the matter for fresh consideration where further enquiry is needed, and no jurisdictional infirmity arises merely because the grounds were not specifically pleaded. The challenge therefore failed, and the remand for fresh assessment was sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to set aside the assessment and remand the matter for fresh consideration on grounds not specifically taken in the memorandum of appeal, but urged during hearing and requiring scrutiny of the accounts and documents.

Analysis: In tax appeals, the appellate authority is not confined to the precise grounds set out in the memorandum of appeal and may enter into the assessment process on its own initiative. Grounds advanced during arguments may also be considered, as a tax appellate forum functions substantially like the assessing authority and must apply its mind to material and submissions relevant to the controversy. Since the Tribunal directed fresh examination of the accounts and documents and afforded the assessee another opportunity to substantiate the claim, no jurisdictional infirmity or violation of principle was shown.

Conclusion: The Tribunal was competent to remand the matter, and the challenge to its order failed.

Final Conclusion: The revision was rejected, and the Tribunal's remand for fresh assessment was sustained.

Ratio Decidendi: A tax appellate authority may consider relevant grounds and material raised during hearing, even if not specifically pleaded in the memorandum of appeal, and may remand the matter for further enquiry or fresh assessment within its appellate jurisdiction.

---