Developed land sale treated as taxable GST supply, with construction-services rate and land-inclusive valuation applied.
Sale of a developed plot, where drainage, water supply, electricity, levelling, roads and street lighting have been provided, was treated as more than a bare transfer of land and therefore as a taxable supply of services under GST. The development works were held to materially change the land's character, usability and value and to be integrally connected with proposed construction, bringing the transaction within paragraph 5(b) of Schedule II. GST was then applied at the construction-services rate, and valuation was directed to follow paragraph 2 of Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate), treating the land component as one third of the total amount charged.
Issues: (i) Whether the sale of a developed plot of land, after carrying out development activities such as drainage, water supply, electricity, levelling, roads and street lighting, constitutes a taxable supply under GST and falls within paragraph 5(b) of Schedule II; (ii) if taxable, whether the transaction is liable to GST at the rate prescribed for construction services and whether the valuation is to be determined under paragraph 2 of Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate).
Issue (i): Whether the sale of a developed plot of land, after carrying out development activities such as drainage, water supply, electricity, levelling, roads and street lighting, constitutes a taxable supply under GST and falls within paragraph 5(b) of Schedule II.
Analysis: The developed land was treated as materially different from barren land because the development works changed its usability, character and value. The development activities were held to be integrally connected with the proposed construction on the land and not a mere sale of land simpliciter. Paragraph 5(b) of Schedule II, which treats construction of a complex, building, civil structure or a part thereof as supply of services, was applied to hold that the development-linked sale had the character of a taxable service. Reliance on the exemption for sale of land was rejected on the footing that the transaction involved more than a bare transfer of land.
Conclusion: The sale of developed land was held to be liable to GST and was brought within paragraph 5(b) of Schedule II.
Issue (ii): If taxable, whether the transaction is liable to GST at the rate prescribed for construction services and whether the valuation is to be determined under paragraph 2 of Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate).
Analysis: The applicable rate entry for construction services under Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) was applied. The decision further held that where the supply involves transfer of land, the valuation mechanism in paragraph 2 of the notification governs the tax base by deeming the land component to be one third of the total amount charged and taxing the balance as the supply value.
Conclusion: GST was held payable at the construction-services rate, and valuation was directed to be computed in accordance with paragraph 2 of Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate).
Final Conclusion: The advance ruling was set aside and the appeal succeeded, with the sale of developed land held taxable under the GST framework as a construction-related supply.
Ratio Decidendi: Where land is sold after substantial development works that materially enhance its usability and are integrally connected with the proposed construction on it, the transaction is not a mere sale of land but a taxable supply of services under GST, to be valued under the special land-inclusive valuation rule in the applicable rate notification.
TaxTMI 
AI Drafter ✕
TaxTMI 
