Transit document omission cannot sustain penalty without evidence of tax evasion intent in a stock transfer movement.

Penalty for transit-document defects cannot be sustained on a bare clerical omission where the record shows no intention to evade tax. The goods were accompanied by stock transfer papers, including Form 38, and the only defect was that column 6 was left blank. The court applied the principle that penalty under Section 54(1)(14) of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008 requires relevant material showing conscious evasion, and a blank column alone is insufficient when the goods are otherwise identifiable and the stock transfer character is not contradicted. The penalty and appellate order were set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether penalty could be sustained merely because column 6 of Form 38 was left blank, in the absence of material showing an intention to evade tax.

Analysis: The goods were intercepted while being transported along with stock transfer documents, including Form 38 and other supporting papers. The omission was confined to non-filling of column 6. The governing principle applied was that penalty under Section 54(1)(14) of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008 cannot rest on a bare clerical omission alone. The authority must record satisfaction, on relevant material, that there was an intention to evade payment of tax. Where the transaction was a stock transfer and the goods were otherwise identifiable from the accompanying documents, the absence of a filled column did not by itself establish guilty intent. The revisional court also found no material contradicting the stock transfer character of the movement of goods.

Conclusion: The penalty and the appellate order were unsustainable and were set aside. The revisionist succeeded.

Ratio Decidendi: Penalty for procedural defects in transit documents cannot be imposed unless the record discloses a conscious intention to evade tax; a blank column in Form 38, by itself, is insufficient where the transaction is otherwise supported by accompanying documents and no adverse material exists.

---