Post-import demurrage excluded from customs value, while belated classification challenge defeated exemption benefit.
Demurrage charges incurred after goods reach the Indian port are treated as post-importation expenses and do not form part of the customs assessable value, so the valuation demand fails on that point. The claimed exemption notifications were denied because the goods had been consistently declared under the disputed tariff heading in provisional bills of entry without protest, and the classification challenge was raised too late. On that basis, the reduced-rate benefit was not available.
Issues: (i) Whether demurrage charges were includible in the assessable value of the imported goods. (ii) Whether the importer was entitled to the benefit of the claimed exemption notifications in respect of the goods classified under the disputed tariff heading.
Issue (i): Whether demurrage charges were includible in the assessable value of the imported goods.
Analysis: The issue was treated as settled by the settled position that demurrage is incurred after the goods reach the Indian port and is therefore a post-importation expense. On that basis, such charges do not form part of the assessable value for customs valuation purposes.
Conclusion: Demurrage charges were not includible in the assessable value, and the related demand was set aside.
Issue (ii): Whether the importer was entitled to the benefit of the claimed exemption notifications in respect of the goods classified under the disputed tariff heading.
Analysis: The benefit of the notifications was declined because the goods had been consistently declared under the same tariff heading in the provisional bills of entry without protest, and the classification dispute was not raised at the relevant stage. In those circumstances, the claim to the reduced rate under the exemption notifications was not entertained.
Conclusion: The importer was not entitled to the benefit of the exemption notifications.
Final Conclusion: The demand relating to demurrage was annulled, but the claim for exemption benefit failed, so the appeals succeeded only to the limited extent of the valuation issue.
Ratio Decidendi: Demurrage paid after importation is not part of customs assessable value, while exemption benefits cannot be claimed on a fresh classification plea raised belatedly when the goods were earlier declared under the disputed heading without protest.
TaxTMI 
AI Drafter ✕
TaxTMI 
