Statutory police security services held outside taxable Security Agency Service where charges were treasury-based and non-commercial

A State police department providing armed security personnel under the Kerala State Police Act was treated as performing a statutory and sovereign function, not as a commercial security business. Charges were fixed under the governing legal framework and credited to the Government treasury, and the applicable circular stated that such collections by public authorities for mandatory functions do not attract service tax where no business service is involved. On that basis, provision of police security personnel was held outside Security Agency Service, and the service tax demand and connected penalties were unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Police Department's provision of armed security personnel to Government departments, public sector undertakings and private persons was taxable as Security Agency Service under the Finance Act, 1994.

Analysis: The activity was undertaken by a State Police Department in discharge of statutory obligations under the Kerala State Police Act. The charges collected were fixed under the statutory framework and deposited into the Government treasury. The governing circular clarified that amounts collected by sovereign/public authorities for statutory and mandatory functions, and credited to the treasury, do not attract service tax where the activity is not a business service. The issue had also been consistently answered by earlier Tribunal decisions in favour of the police authorities.

Conclusion: The provision of police security personnel in the facts of the case was not covered by Security Agency Service and no service tax liability arose.

Final Conclusion: The service tax demand and connected penalties could not be sustained, and the appeals succeeded with consequential relief.

Ratio Decidendi: A State police department performing statutory and sovereign functions, and collecting charges under the governing law for deposit into the Government treasury, is not engaged in the business of providing taxable Security Agency Service.

---