Immediate entry in excise stock records not required where rules allow date-wise maintenance of raw material accounts.

The excise account-maintenance scheme under Rule 173G(4) read with Rules 53 and 226 required recording of production, storage and materials received or consumed, but it did not expressly demand instantaneous entry of raw materials in Form IV on arrival in the factory. The Court held that Form IV could be maintained as a running, date-wise account with balances taken at the end of working hours, and in the absence of a clear statutory requirement for immediate receipt entry, non-compliance was not established. Confiscation, penalty and revisional orders were therefore unsustainable and were set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessees were bound under the Central Excise Rules, 1944 to enter raw materials and components in Form IV immediately on receipt in the factory, and whether confiscation, penalty and allied orders could be sustained for alleged non-entry at that stage.

Analysis: Rule 173G(4) read with Rules 53 and 226 required maintenance of accounts of production, manufacture, storage, delivery and disposal of goods, together with materials received or consumed, and kept for inspection. Form IV was treated as a running account of raw material and components with date-wise entries, opening balance, closing balance and related particulars. On a plain reading of the form and the rules, the Court held that the scheme did not require immediate entry of raw materials the moment they entered the mill premises. The relevant account could be completed on a date-wise basis and the closing balance drawn at the end of working hours. In the absence of any clear requirement that receipt entries had to be made instantaneously, and since the record did not show non-compliance on the preceding day, the alleged breach was not established.

Conclusion: The confiscation, penalty and revisional orders were unsustainable and were set aside, with the result that the petitioners succeeded.

Ratio Decidendi: Where excise rules require maintenance of a stock and production account but do not expressly mandate instantaneous entry on receipt of raw materials, penal consequences cannot be imposed for failure to make such immediate entry.

---