Supreme Court Quashes High Court's Decision on VAT Assessment Appeals

The Supreme Court allowed the appeals and quashed the High Court's judgments that had quashed fresh assessment orders made by the Assessing Officer for registered dealers holding VAT Registration. The Court held that the dealers should have appealed to the First Appellate Authority instead of seeking writ relief directly. Since the fresh assessment orders favored the State and were made after remand by the First Appellate Authority, the High Court's decision was deemed unsustainable. Consequently, the Supreme Court set aside the writ petitions without any order on costs.

---

---

Issues:
Appeal against High Court judgment quashing fresh assessment orders.

Analysis:
The Supreme Court heard appeals against the High Court's decision to quash fresh assessment orders made by the Assessing Officer for registered dealers holding VAT Registration. The High Court allowed writ petitions by the dealers challenging the fresh assessment orders. The Court noted that the dealers should have first appealed to the First Appellate Authority before seeking writ relief directly. The fresh assessment orders were made after remand by the First Appellate Authority, while revisional proceedings were ongoing. The Court highlighted that the High Court did not assess the merits of the fresh assessment orders. Since the fresh assessments favored the State, the dealers should have appealed to the First Appellate Authority instead of seeking writ relief. Consequently, the Supreme Court held that the High Court's decision to quash the fresh assessment orders was unsustainable. Therefore, the Supreme Court allowed the appeals, quashed the High Court's judgments, and set aside the writ petitions without any order on costs.

---