Court Directs Lower Tax Rate under India-Switzerland DTAA

The court set aside the respondent's decision prescribing a 10% tax rate on dividends and directed the issuance of a certificate for a 5% tax withholding rate under the India-Switzerland Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) with the Most Favoured Nation (MFN) clause for the specific dividend amount in the Financial Year 2021-22. Emphasizing the importance of following established legal principles and binding court decisions, the court ruled in favor of the petitioner, highlighting the necessity of adhering to past judgments and directing compliance with the applicable tax rate as per the DTAA.

---

---

Issues:
Challenge to certificate and communication under Income Tax Act, 1961 for tax withholding rate on dividend under India-Switzerland DTAA with MFN clause.

Analysis:
The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging a certificate and communication issued by the respondent regarding the tax withholding rate on dividends. The petitioner sought directions for a fresh certificate prescribing a 5% tax withholding rate on a specific dividend amount for the Financial Year 2021-22 under the India-Switzerland Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) read with the Most Favoured Nation (MFN) clause. The impugned orders prescribed a 10% tax rate on dividends, contrary to the applicable 5% rate under the DTAA and related agreements.

The petitioner argued that the MFN clause in the India-Switzerland DTAA allows for a lower tax rate on dividend income if India enters into agreements with other OECD member countries at a lower rate. Referring to past judgments, the petitioner contended that the issue raised in the petition has already been settled by the court. The respondent's decision was deemed to contravene established legal principles, and the respondent was criticized for not following binding court decisions.

In response, the respondent argued that no notification had been issued by the Government of India to allow the lower tax rate from agreements with other countries. The respondent also mentioned the intention to file Special Leave Petitions before the Supreme Court challenging the court's decisions in similar cases. However, the court found that the issues raised in the present petition were already settled by previous judgments, emphasizing the importance of following binding jurisdictional decisions without waiting for potential appeals.

The court, after considering the arguments from both parties and the precedents cited, set aside the impugned order and directed the respondent to issue a certificate under Section 197 of the Income Tax Act indicating a 5% tax rate on dividends as applicable under the India-Switzerland DTAA. The court highlighted the need to adhere to established legal principles and previous court decisions, disposing of the writ petition with the given directions.

---