University services including examinations, banking, postal and catering facilities exempt from service tax under Section 66-D

The Madras HC ruled that a university's services including granting affiliation, conducting examinations, and providing campus facilities like banks, post offices, and canteens to students, staff, and faculty are exempt from service tax under Section 66-D of the Finance Act and the Mega Exemption Notification 2012. The court rejected the revenue department's narrow interpretation of "conduct of examination," holding that universities primarily conduct examinations with colleges as facilitators. Allied services such as renting immovable property for banking, postal, and catering services were deemed part of educational services and thus exempt. The petition was allowed, and the service tax demand was held untenable.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Whether the services rendered by the petitioner university by granting affiliation and its allied activities are exempted services within the meaning of Section 66-D of the Finance Act and the Mega Exemption Notification.
2. Whether the services related to renting immovable property for purposes like bank, post office, and canteen are exempted from service tax.

Issue-Wise Detailed Analysis:

1. Exemption of Affiliation Services:
- The petitioner university, established under the Madurai Kamaraj University Act, 1965, functions as an affiliating university, holding examinations and conferring degrees.
- The Finance Act, 1994, introduced service tax, which was expanded over time. From 2012, Section 65-B(44) defined "service," and Section 66-B imposed a 12% tax on services except those in the negative list under Section 66-D.
- Clause (l) of Section 66-D (effective from 01.07.2012 to 13.05.2016) exempted educational services like pre-school to higher secondary education, education as part of a recognized curriculum, and approved vocational courses.
- The Mega Exemption Notification (20.06.2012) and subsequent amendments (including Notification No.9/16) further clarified exemptions for educational institutions.
- The primary function of the university includes granting affiliations and conducting examinations, integral to imparting education.
- The court found that services related to affiliation and examination are part of educational services, exempt from service tax under Section 66-D and the Mega Exemption Notification.
- The court rejected the revenue's argument that the university does not directly impart education, emphasizing the expanded meaning of educational services to include faculty and staff services.

2. Renting of Immovable Property:
- The university provides services like renting space for banks, post offices, and canteens within its campus, which benefit students, faculty, and staff.
- Clause 9 of the Mega Exemption Notification includes services provided by educational institutions to their students, faculty, and staff, such as transportation, catering, and housekeeping.
- The court held that these services are part of the educational services and thus exempt from service tax.
- The court disagreed with the revenue's reliance on the Advance Ruling Authority's narrow interpretation, asserting that the expanded meaning of educational services includes these allied activities.

Conclusion:
- The court concluded that the entire demand for service tax by the respondent revenue on the petitioner university's services, including affiliation and renting of immovable property, is unlawful and against the statutory provisions.
- The impugned order was set aside, and the writ petition was allowed, exempting the petitioner university from service tax for the period in question.

---