Dispute over Food Preparation Product Classification: Authority Rules 18% GST Rate

The case involved a dispute regarding the classification and applicable GST rate for various food preparation products. The authority determined that the products should be classified under CTH 2106 with an 18% GST rate, as they are food preparations requiring further processing before consumption. The ruling specified the applicable tax rates for each product listed in the application under CTH 2106.

---

---

ISSUES PRESENTED AND CONSIDERED

1. Whether the assorted ready-to-prepare food mixes (dosai mixes, idly mixes, tiffin mixes, health mixes, porridge mixes) are classifiable under Chapter 11 (notably CTH 1106), Chapter 19 (CTH 1901), Chapter 23 (CTH 2302) or Chapter 21 (CTH 2106) of the Customs Tariff/HSN for GST purposes.

2. Whether the Circular on "Chhatua/Sattu" (mixture of flours of pulses and cereals) applies to the applicant's products and thereby supports classification under CTH 1106.

3. Application of General Rules of Interpretation (GRI) - especially Rules 2(b) and 3 - to mixtures/composite food preparations and determination of the heading which gives the products their essential character.

4. Consequent GST rate applicable to the products once classification is determined (i.e., whether the products attract the 18% entry under the residuary CTH 2106 or other specified rates under other headings).

ISSUE-WISE DETAILED ANALYSIS

Issue 1 - Proper classification: whether the products fall under CTH 1106, 1901, 2302 or 2106

Legal framework: Interpretive rules of the First Schedule to the Customs Tariff Act (Section & Chapter Notes, Explanatory Notes to HSN) apply per Explanation (iii)-(iv) to Notification No.1/2017-CT(Rate). GRI (Rules 2(b) and 3) govern classification of mixtures/composite goods.

Precedent treatment: The applicant relied on prior AARs (a Gujarat AAR classifying certain instant mixes under CTH 1106/1901 and a Tamil Nadu AAR on other food preparations). Those authorities were cited but not adopted wholesale.

Interpretation and reasoning: Examination of product compositions, packaging and usage showed (a) contents are powders/granules/strips requiring further mixing/cooking (not sold as ready-to-eat batter); (b) ingredients include cereals, pulses, salts and additives where multiple constituents are essential to the final savoury and not mere additives; (c) many items are composite mixes where no single constituent can be treated as merely additive or as solely determinative of essential character.

Application of HSN/Chapter notes:

- CTH 1106 (flour/meal/powder of dried leguminous vegetables, sago or products of Chapter 8): applies where product is obtained essentially by milling of a single category (e.g., pulses) with only minimal additives; Chapter excludes prepared flours intended as food preparations.

- CTH 1901 (food preparations of flour/meal/starch etc.): covers preparations usable by simply mixing/boiling in water/milk and typically where product is a preparation of flour/vegetable origin and is not classified elsewhere.

- CTH 2302 (bran/sharps/residues): covers milling by-products or residues not meeting Chapter-11 criteria - requires evidentiary proof (tests) that products are sifting residues or non-complying milling by-products.

- CTH 2106 (food preparations not elsewhere specified): residuary heading for food preparations for human consumption not covered by other headings; includes preparations for use either directly or after processing (e.g., cooking) and mixtures of foodstuffs/chemicals incorporated to make food preparations.

Reasoned conclusion: Products are not simple milled flours of a single class (CTH 1106) because they contain multiple essential ingredients and are marketed as preparations for specific savories rather than generic pulse flours; they are not suited for mere reconstitution by boiling or simple mixing as contemplated by CTH 1901; no test evidence was furnished to support classification as milling residues under CTH 2302. Applying GRI 2(b)/3, the goods are best classified by their essential character as prepared food mixes not covered elsewhere. Therefore the products fall under the residuary heading CTH 2106.

Ratio vs. Obiter: The determination that these specific compositions fall under CTH 2106 is ratio for this set of facts; the observations distinguishing cited AARs (differences in composition, lack of testing) are binding to the extent of factual distinctions and form part of the reasoning (ratio), not mere obiter.

Issue 2 - Applicability of the "Chhatua/Sattu" Circular and classification under CTH 1106

Legal framework: Administrative circulars (clarifications) are relevant but must be applied only where factual criteria match the circular's scope. Circular stated that mixtures of flours of ground pulses and cereals (Sattu/Chhatua) that are simply milled and only slightly improved by additives may be classifiable under HSN 1106 (with NIL/5% depending on branding/packing).

Precedent treatment: Applicant invoked Circular No.80/54/2018 and prior AARs that applied it.

Interpretation and reasoning: The Authority compared the applicant's product compositions to the circular's subject-Sattu is essentially a mixture principally of ground pulses/cereals as a flour ingredient. The applicant's mixes, however, incorporate multiple essential components (cereals, pulses, hydrogenated fat, spices, leaves, chemical additives) designed as finished preparatory food mixes for specific savories, not as basic milled flour commodity. The presence of non-trivial additives and the marketed function (ready-to-prepare for particular dishes) distinguish these products from the circular's Sattu example.

Ratio vs. Obiter: The Authority distinguished the circular's applicability on factual grounds - this distinction is part of the operative reasoning (ratio) for classification under CTH 2106.

Conclusion: Circular on Chhatua/Sattu is inapplicable to the products as presented; CTH 1106 does not apply.

Issue 3 - Application of GRI for mixtures and determination of essential character

Legal framework: GRI 2(b) treats references to materials as including mixtures; GRI 3 prescribes priority (most specific heading; essential character; last in numerical order).

Interpretation and reasoning: Headings CTH 1106, 1901 and 2302 were examined for specificity. CTH 1106 and 1901 could be invoked only if products met narrowly defined criteria (pure milled flours or preparations usable by simple mixing/boiling). Given equal importance of multiple constituent ingredients and the marketed identity as specific food mixes (idli/dosa/tiffin etc.), the essential character is that of a prepared food mix not covered elsewhere. Hence, Rule 3(b) points to classification under the heading giving essential character - CTH 2106.

Ratio vs. Obiter: Application of GRI to reach CTH 2106 is central ratio supporting the ruling.

Issue 4 - Applicable GST rate once classified under CTH 2106

Legal framework: Notification No.1/2017-CT(Rate) (as amended) prescribes GST rates by tariff items and schedules. Entry for CTH 2106 in Schedule-III (S.No.23) levies 18% (9% CGST + 9% SGST) on "food preparations not elsewhere specified or included", with certain items excepted in other entries (e.g., idli/dosa batter under a separate lower entry when sold as batter).

Interpretation and reasoning: The products are powders/granules (not batter/ready-to-eat) and are classifiable under CTH 2106; they do not fall within the limited exception (idli/dosa batter) added at S.No.100A because the item sold is not batter but mix requiring final preparation. Thus entry S.No.23 of Schedule-III applies.

Conclusion: The applicable GST rate is 18% (9% CGST + 9% SGST) and HSN classification is CTH 2106 for each listed product. This is the operative ruling (ratio) for the products as described and tested by the applicant's provided compositions and packaging information.

FINAL CONCLUSION (RATIO)

All products described (dosai mixes, idly mixes, tiffin mixes, health mixes, porridge mixes as itemised) are classified under HSN/CTH 2106 (Food preparations not elsewhere specified or included) and attract GST at 18% (9% CGST + 9% SGST) under the applicable notification entry for food preparations not elsewhere specified.

---