Excise valuation of gas cylinders cannot include valve value where valves are separately manufactured and sold apart.

Valves fitted to gas cylinders were not treated as part of the cylinders for central excise valuation because the cylinders, valves and regulators were separately manufactured under distinct licences, from different materials and by different processes, and cylinders were often sold without valves. The mere fact that valves were necessary for the cylinders' use did not justify adding their value to the assessable value of the cylinders under the tariff entry for containers. The revisional order was therefore set aside and the inclusion of valve value in the cylinders' assessable value was held invalid.

---

---

Issues: Whether the value of valves fitted to gas cylinders could be included in the assessable value of the gas cylinders for central excise purposes.

Analysis: The cylinders, valves, and regulators were manufactured separately, under distinct industrial licences, from different materials and by different processes. The record showed that cylinders were in fact sold without valves in many cases. Mere necessity of the valves for the use of the cylinders did not make the valves part of the cylinders for valuation purposes, nor did it justify adding their value to the assessable value of the cylinders under the tariff entry for containers.

Conclusion: The inclusion of the value of valves in the assessable value of the gas cylinders was ? No, invalid; the revisional order was set aside and the petitioners succeeded on this issue.

---