Software distribution payments are not royalty where no copyright rights are transferred, so no tax deduction at source applies.

A payment for software or integrated hardware-software supplies under a distribution arrangement is not royalty where no copyright interest or right to use copyright is transferred. Applying the Supreme Court ruling on software payments, the Tribunal treated the receipts from sales to Indian distributors or customers as non-taxable royalty income in India. Because the receipts were not chargeable to tax as royalty, the tax deduction at source provisions did not apply, and the remaining issues were treated as academic.

---

---

Issues: Whether the consideration received for sale of software and hardware to Indian distributors or customers constituted royalty taxable in India and whether tax was deductible at source under the Income-tax Act.

Analysis: The Tribunal applied the ruling of the Supreme Court on software payments and held that the distribution agreements did not confer any interest or right in copyright so as to amount to use of, or the right to use, copyright. On the facts, the receipts from software and the integrated hardware-software transactions did not create taxable royalty income in India. Once the receipts were not taxable as royalty, the provisions governing deduction of tax at source were not attracted. The remaining grounds were treated as academic.

Conclusion: The issue was decided in favour of the assessee. The software and hardware receipts were held not to be royalty, and no TDS liability arose.

Ratio Decidendi: A payment for resale or use of software under a distribution arrangement, where no copyright interest is transferred, is not royalty and does not attract tax deduction at source.

---