Public-auction sales requirement controls tea exemption; non-auction quantities cannot be counted for eligibility under the notification.

The exemption under Notification No. 161/71-C.E. depended on proof that at least 50 per cent of the loose tea manufactured during the relevant three-year period was actually sold in public auction and that the average price realised from those auction sales was below the prescribed limit. Quantities used as tea samples or later sold by private negotiation could not be treated as public-auction sales for computing either the qualifying percentage or the average sale price. The notification had to be applied according to its express terms, and its scope could not be enlarged by including sales made otherwise than at public auction. The exemption claim was therefore rejected and the appellate order was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether, for claiming the benefit of the exemption under Notification No. 161/71-C.E. dated 1-7-1975, the quantity of tea samples used in auction and the quantity not sold at public auction but sold later by private negotiation could be treated as sold in public auction for computing the required average sale price and qualifying percentage.

Analysis: The notification required the manufacturer to prove that, during the specified three-year period, not less than 50 per cent of the loose tea manufactured had been sold in public auction and that the average price realised for such public-auction sales was less than Rs. 6.60 per kg. The claimed inclusion of quantities not actually sold in public auction would expand the scope of the exemption beyond its terms. The exemption depended on the certificate and proof of the price realised at auction, and only tea actually sold by public auction could be counted for that purpose.

Conclusion: The claim for exemption was rejected, and the order in appeal was upheld as correct in law.

Final Conclusion: The revision failed because the exemption notification had to be applied on the basis of actual public-auction sales, without enlarging its scope to include quantities sold otherwise.

---