Proprietary medicine classification turns on the label as a whole, not on mandatory manufacturer details alone.

Medicines are not proprietary medicines under Tariff Item 14E merely because the label displays the manufacturer's name and mandatory particulars required by the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules. The decisive test is whether the label as a whole, including printing, size, design and lettering, creates an association of the preparation with the manufacturer so as to identify it as proprietary. Here, the manufacturer's name was not more prominent than the product name and the label only reflected required regulatory particulars. The medicines were therefore held not to be proprietary medicines, and the classification adopted by the Collector was set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether the medicines manufactured and cleared by the appellant were proprietary medicines falling under Tariff Item 14E on the basis of the labels used.

Analysis: The disputed labels were examined to see whether the manner of printing, size, design, and lettering created an association of the preparations with the manufacturer so as to make the goods proprietary medicines. The decisive question was whether the manufacturer's name on the labels was so prominent as to alter the character of the preparations. The Board found that the wording showing the manufacturing details was only what was required under Rule 94 of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945, and did not make the medicines proprietary in nature. It further found that the manufacturer's name was not more prominent than the name of the preparation.

Conclusion: The medicines were not proprietary medicines within Tariff Item 14E, and the order of the Collector was set aside in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Mere display of the manufacturer's name and mandatory label particulars does not, without more, render a medicinal preparation a proprietary medicine; classification depends on whether the label as a whole creates identification of the product with the manufacturer.

---