High Court clarifies bond vs. bank guarantee for goods release in tax case

The Gujarat High Court clarified that a bond without a bank guarantee was sufficient for the release of goods/vehicle in a Special Civil Application. The applicant was ordered to deposit Rs. 18 Lakh towards tax and penalty and execute a bond for the remaining Rs. 52 Lakh. Despite respondent No.2's confusion between a bond and a bank guarantee, the Court emphasized the release based on the deposit and bond specified. The Court refrained from further action despite respondent No.2's delay, instructing release upon compliance. The judgment highlighted the distinction between a bond and a bank guarantee, affirming the bond's legality without collateral requirements.

---

---

Issues: Clarification on the requirement of bond and bank guarantee for release of goods.

In this judgment by the Gujarat High Court, the applicant sought clarification that the "bond" mentioned in a previous order did not need to be accompanied by a bank guarantee/security for the release of goods/vehicle. The main matter involved a Special Civil Application where the Court ordered the provisional release of goods pending confiscation proceedings, with the applicant required to deposit Rs. 18 Lakh towards tax and penalty, and execute a bond for the balance amount of Rs. 52 Lakh. The Court noted the respondent No.2's lack of understanding regarding the distinction between a bond and a bank guarantee, emphasizing that the goods should be released based on the deposit and bond as specified by the Court. Despite the delay in compliance by respondent No.2, the Court refrained from further action. The Court reiterated its direction for the release of goods upon the specified deposit and bond execution. The Court instructed the learned AGP to clarify the consequences to respondent No.2 and emphasized that the bond required was in accordance with the law, distinct from a bank guarantee which necessitates collateral. The judgment clarified the requirement for a bond without a bank guarantee and disposed of the application accordingly.

---