Authority Unable to Rule on GST Classification, ITC, and Refund Eligibility Due to Lack of Documentation

The authority could not make a decision on the issues raised by the applicant regarding the classification of services as "Mixed supply" or "Composite supply," applicable HSN code and GST rate, eligibility for Input Tax Credit (ITC), and the exporter client's eligibility for a GST refund due to the absence of relevant documents. The questions posed were deemed hypothetical, and without concrete agreements, the authority could not provide a ruling.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Classification of services as "Mixed supply" or "Composite supply".
2. Applicable HSN code and GST rate for the bundled services.
3. Eligibility to avail Input Tax Credit (ITC).
4. Exporter client's eligibility to claim a refund of GST paid on outward supply invoices.

Detailed Analysis:

Issue 1: Classification of Services as "Mixed supply" or "Composite supply"
The applicant sought clarification on whether their bundled services provided at a single consolidated rate would be considered a "Mixed supply" under Section 2(74) of the CGST Act, 2017, or a "Composite supply". The applicant argued that the services are not naturally bundled and can be provided independently, thus qualifying as a "Mixed supply". The authority noted that the applicant's scenario is hypothetical as no agreement has materialized, and therefore, no decision could be made without relevant documents.

Issue 2: Applicable HSN Code and GST Rate
The applicant inquired about the applicable HSN code and corresponding GST rate for the bundled services, where the highest rate of service in the bundle is 18%. The authority reiterated that without the submission of an agreement or relevant documents, it is not possible to determine the applicable HSN code and GST rate.

Issue 3: Eligibility to Avail Input Tax Credit (ITC)
The applicant sought to know if they could avail ITC on GST paid for commercial vehicles, repair and maintenance costs, and inward supplies related to the packaged outward supply. The authority again stated that without the submission of relevant documents, no decision could be made on the eligibility to avail ITC.

Issue 4: Exporter Client's Eligibility to Claim Refund of GST
The applicant asked whether their exporter client would be eligible to claim a refund of the GST paid on their outward supply invoices. The authority concluded that without an agreement or relevant documents, it is not possible to determine the eligibility for a GST refund.

Conclusion:
The authority ruled that due to the non-submission of copies of the agreement or any other relevant documents, no decision could be taken on any of the issues raised by the applicant. The questions posed were hypothetical, and the lack of materialized agreements made it impossible for the authority to provide a ruling.

---