Port licence fee not taxable as franchise services where operators acted independently and no representational right was granted.

Licence fee collected by a Port Trust for permitting third-party crane operators to work within the port area is not taxable as franchise services where no representational right is granted. Franchise taxability requires a right to use the franchisor's identity in connection with goods or services; here, the operators rendered services in their own name, paid service tax on their own activity, and the Port Trust did not provide a service to them. The fee was therefore consideration for allowing port-related operations, not for conferring a franchise, and the tax demand could not be sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether the licence fee collected by a Port Trust for permitting third-party crane operators to operate cranes within the port area is taxable as franchise services.

Analysis: The activity arose from the Port Trust's statutory powers and obligations in relation to port operations. Taxability as franchise services requires a grant of representational right in connection with goods or services identifiable with the franchisor. On the facts, the crane operators provided services in their own name, discharged service tax on their own activity, and the Port Trust did not render any service to them. The licence fee was received for permitting performance of port-related functions, not for conferring a franchise of the Port Trust.

Conclusion: The licence fee was not taxable under franchise services and the demand could not be sustained.

---