Securities transaction tax liability is confined to the client-code collection mechanism, not broker errors beyond it.

Under the securities transaction tax framework, liability is tied to the statutory collection mechanism under the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2004 and Rule 3 of the STT Rules, 2004, which look to trades executed under the relevant client code through member brokers and payment to the Central Government. Where tax was in fact collected through brokers under client codes and credited to the Government, the stock exchange could not be fastened with short-collection liability for a broker's failure to use the correct client code or apply the correct rate beyond that mechanism. The addition, interest and penalty were therefore deleted.

---

---

Issues: Whether the stock exchange could be held liable for alleged short collection of securities transaction tax where the tax was collected through member brokers under client codes and credited to the Central Government, and whether the consequent addition, interest and penalty were sustainable.

Analysis: Chapter VII of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2004 makes the securities transaction tax chargeable at the prescribed rate on taxable securities transactions, requires collection by a recognised stock exchange from the purchaser or seller, and provides for payment to the Central Government. The value of the taxable transaction is determined under the statutory mechanism and, under Rule 3 of the Securities Transaction Tax Rules, 2004, the relevant reference is the trades executed under the particular client code through the member broker. On the facts found, the tax had been collected through the brokers under their client codes and credited to the Central Government. Any failure of a broker to use separate client codes or to apply the correct rate could not, on the statutory scheme, be fastened on the stock exchange, which had no mechanism to collect beyond the client code arrangement.

Conclusion: The stock exchange was not liable for the alleged short deduction of securities transaction tax, and the addition as well as the consequential interest and penalty were rightly deleted.

Ratio Decidendi: Under the securities transaction tax framework, the stock exchange's duty is confined to collection and deposit in accordance with the prescribed rate and client-code based valuation mechanism; it is not answerable for a broker's failure to use the correct client code or to collect the correct amount beyond that mechanism.

---