Life Estate and Vested Remainder Trigger Estate Duty on Death of the Life Tenant

A life estate under a will does not become absolute because of an intervening adoption, and the testamentary remainder remains effective. When the life tenant dies, beneficial enjoyment passes to the remainderman, so the event can constitute a taxable passing of property and a cesser of interest for estate duty purposes. The estate duty charge was therefore treated as applicable where the deceased held only a life interest and another beneficiary was entitled to succeed on death, with authorities involving adoptive father or joint family property distinguished on their facts.

---

---

Issues: Whether estate duty was chargeable on the death of a life tenant where the property was subject to a vested remainder in favour of another line of succession, and whether the death brought about a passing of property or cesser of interest within the meaning of the Estate Duty Act, 1953.

Analysis: The property had been bequeathed under a will by which the deceased enjoyed only a life estate, while the vested remainder was created in favour of the successor beneficiary. On the death of the life tenant, the beneficial enjoyment of the property changed hands, and the successor became entitled to possession and income. The earlier adoption did not destroy the testamentary disposition or convert the life tenant's interest into an absolute title. The Court held that the transaction attracted the charging provision because there was a passing of property on death, and independently the life interest ceased on death with a corresponding benefit accruing to the remainderman. The cited authorities relied on by the respondent were distinguished as dealing with different factual and legal settings, particularly property of the adoptive father or joint family property, and not a third party's testamentary estate.

Conclusion: Estate duty was leviable under section 5 and also under section 7 of the Estate Duty Act, 1953, and the assessment order was rightly restored.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a deceased holds only a life estate under a will and the vested remainder is to pass to another on her death, the death effects a taxable passing of property and a cesser of interest for estate duty purposes, even if an adoption has occurred in the chain of succession.

---