CCTV camera classification under tariff heading 8525 8090 upheld as other apparatus, not television cameras.

CCTV cameras imported as CCTV camera and related system equipment were examined under Heading 8525. The tariff structure and HSN note for Heading 8525 did not contain a specific entry for CCTV cameras, so they were not treated as television cameras under Heading 8525 8010. The classification was therefore held to fall under the residuary entry for other apparatus under Heading 8525 8090, consistent with the description in the bill of entry. The Revenue's classification was sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether CCTV cameras imported by the appellant were classifiable under Heading 8525 8010 as television cameras or under Heading 8525 8090 as other apparatus.

Analysis: The dispute turned on the tariff description and the HSN note for Heading 8525. The imported goods were described in the bill of entry as CCTV camera and related CCTV system equipment, and the bill of entry under dispute itself reflected classification under Heading 8525 8090. The classification was examined against the tariff structure, which contains no specific entry for CCTV cameras. The contention that CCTV cameras must be treated as television cameras was rejected because the tariff and HSN note did not support such an inclusion, and the residuary classification for other goods under Heading 8525 8090 was considered appropriate for the goods in dispute.

Conclusion: CCTV cameras were not classifiable under Heading 8525 8010 and were rightly classifiable under Heading 8525 8090.

Final Conclusion: The appeal failed on the tariff classification issue and the Revenue's classification was sustained.

---