VAT registration amendment suffices when a proprietorship becomes a partnership without dissolution and notice is timely filed.

A proprietorship converted into a partnership without dissolution was not required to obtain a fresh VAT registration certificate. Section 17 of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008 permits amendment of an existing certificate when there is a change in name, ownership or constitution, and its Explanation treats a continuing firm with changed constitution as eligible for amendment rather than re-registration. Section 75 and Rule 33 require timely intimation of the change in the prescribed form, and the record showed Form XII was submitted within time. The rejection of the amendment application was therefore unsustainable, and the existing registration had to be amended.

---

---

Issues: Whether a proprietorship concern converted into a partnership firm, with the proprietor continuing as a partner, was required to obtain a fresh registration certificate or whether amendment of the existing registration certificate was sufficient under the VAT regime.

Analysis: Section 17 of the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008 permits amendment of a registration certificate where there is a change in the name, ownership or constitution of the business, and its Explanation declares that where a firm undergoes a change in constitution without dissolution, a fresh certificate is not required. Section 75 requires a dealer to intimate changes in business constitution within the prescribed time, and Rule 33 prescribes the manner and form for such intimation and consequential amendment. The record showed timely submission of Form XII and no finding that the statutory intimation was not given within time. The earlier Division Bench view in a similar situation also supported amendment rather than fresh registration.

Conclusion: Amendment of the existing registration certificate was permissible and a fresh registration was not required. The rejection of the amendment application was unsustainable.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a proprietorship is converted into a partnership without dissolution and the statutory intimation of change is furnished within time, the registration certificate must be amended and a fresh registration cannot be insisted upon.

---