Bank's Foreign Currency Appreciation Taxable as Business Income, High Court Rules

The High Court upheld the Tribunal's decision that the appreciation of foreign currency held by a bank was taxable income as it was part of the bank's business operations and not capital profit. The foreign currency amounts were considered profits made in the course of the bank's business activities, as the bank had the freedom to convert currencies and utilized them for payments. The taxability of the foreign currency appreciations for both assessment years was affirmed in favor of the tax department, with costs awarded to the department, including advocate's fees.

---

---

Issues:
1. Taxability of foreign currency appreciation for assessment year 1967-68.
2. Taxability of foreign currency appreciation for assessment year 1970-71.

Analysis:
The judgment involves two cases concerning the taxability of foreign currency appreciation for different assessment years. The State Bank of Mysore held sums in foreign currencies for making payments to foreign concerns on behalf of its clients in India. The Indian rupee devaluation in 1966 and revaluation of franc and deutschmark in 1969 resulted in appreciation of these foreign currency amounts in terms of Indian rupees. The Income-tax Officer deemed these appreciations as taxable income for the respective assessment years. The Tribunal found that the foreign bank balances were part of the bank's stock-in-trade, and the appreciation was realized through transactions incidental to the banking business. The Tribunal relied on the principle established in Commissioner of Income-tax v. Canara Bank Ltd., where profits from exchange fluctuations during business operations were considered revenue receipts. The Tribunal concluded that the amounts in question constituted income and were taxable.

The Tribunal's decision was upheld by the High Court, stating that the appreciation of foreign currency was part of the bank's business operations and not capital profit. The Court noted that the bank had the freedom to convert foreign currencies into rupees without any restrictions. The bank utilized its foreign bank balances to make payments in foreign currencies and received payments in rupees from clients at revised exchange rates. Therefore, the sums in question were considered profits made in the course of the bank's business activities. Consequently, the questions regarding the taxability of the foreign currency appreciations for both assessment years were answered affirmatively in favor of the department. The department was awarded costs, including advocate's fees.

---