Tribunal Quashes Section 234E Orders, No TCS Collection Required

The Tribunal quashed the orders under section 234E for the assessees Rakesh B. Laddha, Jayesh K. Dangariya, and Parag M. Parsana, as CIT(A) found no TCS collection requirement. For Vishal Enterprise, the matter was remitted to the AO for reassessment based on higher authority's confirmation of no TCS necessity. The appeals were allowed for statistical purposes due to procedural and jurisdictional flaws in the AO's section 234E orders.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Maintainability of appeal against an order passed under section 234E of the Income Tax Act.
2. Requirement for the assessee to collect Tax Collected at Source (TCS) and submit Form No. 27EQ.
3. Validity of orders passed under sections 206C(6) and 206C(7) of the Income Tax Act.
4. Impact of subsequent orders by CIT(A) on the validity of penalties levied under section 234E.

Issue-wise Detailed Analysis:

1. Maintainability of Appeal Against an Order Passed Under Section 234E:
The primary grievance of the assessees was that the CIT(A) erred in confirming the fine levied by the AO under section 234E by holding that no appeal is maintainable against an order passed under this section. The CIT(A) concluded that the order under section 234E for late filing of quarterly statements in Form 27EQ for the period prior to 01/06/2015 is not appealable as per section 246A of the IT Act. This conclusion was based on the judgment of the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court in the case of Rajesh Kourani vs. Union of India, which held that section 200A, as amended from 01/06/2015, allows for the computation of fees under section 234E and makes such orders appealable under section 246A. However, prior to this amendment, no such provision existed, rendering separate orders under section 234E non-appealable.

2. Requirement for the Assessee to Collect TCS and Submit Form No. 27EQ:
The AO determined that the assessees, engaged in the sale of scrap, failed to collect TCS as required under section 206C and also failed to submit Form No. 27EQ within the prescribed time. For instance, in the case of M/s. Vishal Enterprise, scrap worth Rs. 22.68 crores was sold without collecting TCS of Rs. 22.68 lakhs, and Form No. 27EQ was not submitted. Similar defaults were observed in other cases, leading to orders under sections 206C(6) and 206C(7) deeming the assessees as assessee-in-default.

3. Validity of Orders Passed Under Sections 206C(6) and 206C(7):
During the pendency of appeals against these orders, the AO also levied fines under section 234E for delays in submitting Form No. 27EQ. The CIT(A) later found that the assessees had collected Form No. 27C from the purchasers, indicating the scrap was for manufacturing use, thus exempting the assessees from collecting TCS. Consequently, the CIT(A) deleted the demands raised under sections 206C(6) and 206C(7), as the forms were submitted belatedly but before assessment proceedings.

4. Impact of Subsequent Orders by CIT(A) on the Validity of Penalties Levied Under Section 234E:
The Tribunal noted that the subsequent orders of the CIT(A) deleting the TCS demands invalidated the foundation of the penalties levied under section 234E. If no TCS was required to be collected, the non-filing of Form No. 27EQ was a procedural formality. The Tribunal observed that the orders passed under section 234E were dependent on the default of the assessee for TCS collection. With the CIT(A) holding that no TCS was required, the penalties under section 234E became unsustainable.

Conclusion:
The Tribunal quashed the impugned orders under section 234E for the assessees Rakesh B. Laddha, Jayesh K. Dangariya, and Parag M. Parsana, based on the CIT(A)'s findings that no TCS was required. For Vishal Enterprise, the issue was remitted to the AO to re-adjudicate based on the production of higher appellate authority's order confirming no TCS was required. The appeals were allowed for statistical purposes, with the Tribunal emphasizing the procedural and jurisdictional lapses in the AO's orders under section 234E.

---