Tribunal Grants CENVAT Credit for Full Service Tax Payment, Emphasizes Statutory Compliance

The Tribunal allowed the appeal, ruling in favor of the appellant, holding that despite reduced payments for services, full service tax payment as per invoices entitled them to CENVAT Credit. Emphasizing adherence to statutory provisions over circulars and case laws, the Tribunal set aside the Order-in-Appeal, granting consequential relief to the appellant based on past decisions and ensuring no loss to revenue.

---

---

Issues:
Appeal against Order-in-Appeal regarding eligibility of CENVAT Credit on input services.

Analysis:
1. The appellant, a petroleum products manufacturer, availed CENVAT Credit on inputs and input services. During audit, discrepancies were found where the appellant had not paid the full value of input services to service providers, resulting in a show cause notice for ineligible CENVAT Credit.

2. The appellant argued that despite reducing service charges, they paid the full service tax as per invoices, entitling them to CENVAT Credit. They relied on Rule 4(7) of CCR 2004 and various case laws to support their claim.

3. The Revenue contended that the appellant's reduced payments for services rendered made them ineligible for CENVAT Credit as per Rule 4(7) provisions. They emphasized strict adherence to statutory provisions over circulars and case laws.

4. The Tribunal noted that while the appellant paid less for services, they paid the full service tax amount indicated in the invoices. Considering that the excess service tax burden was passed on to the appellant, they were entitled to CENVAT Credit as per the invoices.

5. The Tribunal held that Rule 4(7) did not mandate a proportionate reduction in CENVAT Credit when the service tax was paid in full, despite reduced service payments. Circulars and past decisions supported this interpretation, ensuring no loss to revenue.

6. Following consistent decisions by Coordinate Benches, the Tribunal allowed the appeal, setting aside the impugned order and granting consequential relief to the appellant.

In conclusion, the Tribunal ruled in favor of the appellant, affirming their entitlement to CENVAT Credit based on full payment of service tax as per invoices, despite reduced payments for services rendered.

---