Capital receipt treatment for spontaneous growth trees sold to clear land upheld; no business income or capital gains arose.

Receipts from sale of spontaneous growth trees sold to clear land for further cultivation were held to be capital in nature, because the trees were removed as an impediment to cultivation and there was no object or real prospect of regeneration. The Tribunal applied the settled principle that such receipts are not taxable as business income where the sale is incidental to land clearing rather than a profit-making operation. It also held that section 55(2)(a) does not extend to spontaneous growth trees merely because the cost of acquisition is nil, so no capital gains charge arose. The addition was deleted and the lower appellate order was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether the receipts from sale of spontaneous growth of trees were capital receipts not liable to tax or assessable as business income or capital gains.

Analysis: The receipts arose from sale of trees grown spontaneously without human aid and were realised in the course of clearing land for further cultivation under the plantation plan. The settled principle applied was that where the object of the sale is not regeneration of the trees but removal of trees as an impediment to cultivation, the receipt is capital in nature. The Tribunal relied on the earlier decision approving the view that spontaneous growth trees, once sold without any real possibility or intention of regeneration, do not yield taxable income as business profits. The Court also noted that section 55(2)(a) has no application to spontaneous growth trees because the provision is confined to the specified capital assets enumerated therein and cannot be extended to such trees to create a charge under capital gains where the cost of acquisition is nil.

Conclusion: The receipts from sale of spontaneous growth of trees were capital receipts and not taxable either as business income or as capital gains; the addition was rightly deleted.

Final Conclusion: The Revenue failed to establish that the receipts had the character of taxable income, and the orders of the lower appellate authority were upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: Receipts from sale of spontaneous growth trees, when the sale is effected to clear land for cultivation and there is no object of regeneration, are capital receipts not chargeable to tax; a nil cost of acquisition does not by itself render such receipts taxable unless the statutory charging provisions are otherwise attracted.

---