Prototype vehicle valuation: goods cleared only for testing were not captive consumption under Rule 8; Rule 4 valuation sustained.

Prototype motor vehicles cleared to another unit for roadworthiness testing and certification before commercial production were held not to be captive consumption goods under Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000. Because the prototypes were not consumed in further manufacture and the later commercial vehicles were only subsequent copies of the prototypes, valuation on cost of production basis under Rule 8 read with Rule 11 was inapplicable. Valuation under Rule 4, based on the price of similar goods sold subsequently, was sustained. The departmental challenge to the valuation method therefore failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether prototype motor vehicles cleared to another unit for roadworthiness testing were liable to be valued under Rule 8 read with Rule 11 of the Central Excise Valuation (Determination of Price of Excisable Goods) Rules, 2000 on cost of production basis, or under Rule 4 on the basis of the price of similar goods sold subsequently.

Analysis: The valuation dispute turned on the nature of the clearances. The prototypes were removed for testing and certification as prototypes before commercial production could commence. They were not consumed in the manufacture of further motor vehicles, nor could they be equated with captive consumption for the purpose of Rule 8. The commercially sold vehicles were only subsequent copies of the prototypes, and therefore were not the same as the prototype goods for attracting Rule 8. The authority below had also considered the earlier order in the assessee's own case and the departmental acceptance of similar outcomes in connected proceedings.

Conclusion: Rule 8 was inapplicable and valuation under Rule 4 was sustained. The departmental challenge to the valuation method failed and the appeal was dismissed, in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Prototype goods cleared for testing and certification, and not consumed in further manufacture, are not valued as captive consumption goods under Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000.

---