Valuation of body-built motor vehicles on free-supplied chassis required recomputation of duty, with penalty unsustainable.

Valuation of fabricated motor vehicles built on chassis supplied free of cost required reconsideration of the assessable value under the applicable valuation principles, and the duty demand was sent back for recomputation in line with earlier tribunal directions. The earlier reasoning noted that taxes excluded from assessable value had to be examined before finalising duty. On penalty, the prior orders recorded that no penalty was warranted, and the penalty issue was resolved in favour of the assessee. The operative effect was remand for fresh computation of duty and consequential relief on penalty.

---

---

Issues: Whether the duty payable on fabricated motor vehicles built on chassis supplied free of cost was required to be determined under the valuation method adopted by the assessee or under the valuation rule applied by the department, and whether penalty was sustainable.

Analysis: The dispute concerned valuation of motor vehicles manufactured by body-building on chassis supplied by the OEM. The matter had already been decided in earlier tribunal orders in the same line of cases, where it was held that the contention regarding non-includability of taxes in the assessable value required consideration and that the demand, if necessary, had to be recomputed accordingly. In the same line of reasoning, the tribunal followed its earlier orders and directed the adjudicating authority to recompute the duty demand in the light of the earlier decision. The earlier order also recorded that no penalty was warranted.

Conclusion: The duty dispute was remanded for fresh computation in accordance with the earlier tribunal directions, and the penalty issue was answered in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded to the extent of remand, with consequential relief on penalty and reconsideration of the duty demand.

Ratio Decidendi: Where valuation disputes require reconsideration of assessable value, the demand must be recomputed in light of the applicable valuation principles and penalty cannot stand without a sustainable basis.

---