VAT subsidy in assessable value excluded from central excise valuation where VAT was validly discharged through remission challans.

VAT subsidy discharged through VAT 37B challans under the Rajasthan investment promotion and remission scheme was treated as valid payment of VAT. Applying its earlier identical ruling, the Tribunal held that the subsidy amount was not an amount required to be added to transaction value for central excise valuation under Section 4. The excise demand therefore could not be sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether VAT subsidy received through VAT 37B challans was includible in the assessable value for determining central excise duty under Section 4.

Analysis: The Tribunal followed its earlier decision on an identical issue and held that, under the Rajasthan investment promotion and remission scheme, VAT discharged through VAT 37B challans constituted valid payment of VAT. Relying on the distinction drawn in prior Tribunal decisions, it concluded that such subsidy amounts could not be treated as an amount required to be added to the transaction value for excise purposes.

Conclusion: The VAT subsidy was not includible in the assessable value, and the demand could not be sustained.

---