TaxTMI Login
Just a moment...
Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms. Rules for Better Search
When case Id is present, search is done only for this
of 
of 
No Folders have been created
Are you sure you want to delete "My most important" ?
NOTE:
of of 
All Case Laws
of of All Case Laws
Note
Bookmark
Share
Don't have an account? Register Here
of <h1>Court reviews Revenue appeals on undisclosed investments, cash transactions. Advocate waives notice, undisclosed income scrutinized.</h1> <h3>THE PRINCIPAL COMISSONER OF INCOME TAX 5 Versus SHRI BHAGWANBHAI K PATEL</h3> THE PRINCIPAL COMISSONER OF INCOME TAX 5 Versus SHRI BHAGWANBHAI K PATEL - TMI Issues involved:1. Undisclosed investment on account of Umiya Land2. Undisclosed Investment in Land at Nava Naroda (Karnavati)3. Unexplained investments of Rs. 4,87,98,0004. Addition on account of undisclosed investment in Vastral Land5. Undisclosed investment on account of Naroda (Kathwada) Land6. Unaccounted Payment to Kantibhai (A.Y.199697)7. Addition of Rs. 2,50,000 on account of Unexplained cash (A.Y. 199798)8. Unexplained expenditure/Payments9. Addition on account of Cash Payments to Shri Kantibhai Rs. 16 lacs & Rs. 13 lacs10. Protective addition of Rs. 63,34,924 unexplained cash payment to Arwindbhai Patel11. Unexplained investment in FDRs12. Addition on account of cash received of Rs. 2,07,20,28413. Addition on account of cash payment of Rs. 45,03,516 in A Y 199798 and also of Rs. 75,34,840 in A Y 199798Analysis:1. The appeals filed by the Revenue involve questions related to undisclosed investments in Umiya Land and Land at Nava Naroda, as well as unexplained investments. The Tribunal's decisions on allowing credits for these investments are being challenged by the Revenue.2. The Revenue raised additional questions regarding undisclosed investments in Vastral Land, Naroda (Kathwada) Land, unaccounted payments, unexplained cash, and various other expenditures. The Tribunal's decisions on these matters are under scrutiny.3. The Tribunal's approach to determining the undisclosed income and investments in different scenarios, such as Vastral Land and Naroda (Kathwada) Land, is being questioned by the Revenue.4. The Tribunal's decisions on specific additions and deletions, such as in the case of unexplained cash payments and investments, are being reviewed by the Court.5. The Court found that certain questions related to small sums or matters already addressed in previous assessments were not substantial enough to warrant further consideration.6. The Court acknowledged that some issues were fact-based and that the findings of the lower authorities were concurrent, leading to no significant legal questions arising from those issues.7. The advocate representing the Respondent waived the notice of admission, indicating their readiness to proceed with the case based on the issues raised.This detailed analysis covers the various legal issues and the Court's examination of the Tribunal's decisions on undisclosed investments, unexplained income, and other financial matters raised in the appeals filed by the Revenue.
TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
