Exemption for corrugated trays and pads extended under Chapter 481910 where packing function matched cartons, boxes and cases.

Corrugated trays and corrugated pads made of corrugated paper or paperboard were treated as falling within Chapter Heading 481910, because their packing, safeguarding and transport function was similar to cartons, boxes and cases covered by that heading. The exemption notifications were read liberally, and the phrase "as the case may be" was understood to extend coverage to such similar goods under the relevant tariff entry. On that basis, the goods were considered eligible for exemption under the cited notifications, and the demand and penalty were held unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether corrugated trays and corrugated pads were classifiable under Chapter Heading 481910 and entitled to exemption under Notification No. 4/2006-CE dated 01.03.2006 as amended and Notification No. 12/2012-CE dated 17.03.2012.

Analysis: The exemption notifications covered goods falling under Chapter sub-heading 481910, which includes cartons, boxes and cases of corrugated paper or paperboard. The tariff structure showed that goods under this heading were split into boxes under tariff item 48191010 and other goods under tariff item 48191090. The products in question were corrugated trays and pads, used in trade parlance for packing, safeguarding and transporting bottles and cans. Their functional use was similar to cartons, boxes and cases. The expression "as the case may be" in the exemption condition was read liberally to cover similar products made of corrugated paper and paperboard.

Conclusion: Corrugated trays and pads were held to fall within Chapter Heading 481910, specifically under the "other" category, and were entitled to the exemption benefit.

Final Conclusion: The demand and penalty were unsustainable, and the order-in-original was set aside, resulting in relief to the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Where goods of corrugated paper or paperboard perform the same packing and safeguarding function as cartons, boxes or cases and fall within the relevant tariff heading, exemption notification coverage is to be construed liberally to extend to such goods.

---