Quality certification marks are not intellectual property rights; service tax applies only when a real right is licensed.

A quality mark used under the BIS framework for statutory certification and consumer protection does not, by itself, constitute an intellectual property right. Service tax under the Intellectual Property Right service entry applies only where a genuine intellectual property right is transferred or licensed, or permission to use it is granted. Because the hall mark was only a conformity and quality assurance mark, and not a trade mark-type right belonging to the appellant, the charges collected under the scheme were not taxable as IPR service. The service tax demand was therefore unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the hall marking scheme and the charges collected thereunder constituted an Intellectual Property Right service liable to service tax.

Analysis: The taxable entry for Intellectual Property Right service applies only where there is transfer of, or permission to use, an intellectual property right. The hall mark used under the BIS scheme was found to be only a quality assurance mark indicating conformity to standards, and not an intellectual property right belonging to the appellant. The judgment further noted that the mark was protected under the BIS framework and that the appellant was not granting any trade mark-type licence or permission for use of an intellectual property right. The levy had therefore been founded on an incorrect understanding of both the statutory entry and the nature of the hall mark.

Conclusion: The activity did not amount to provision of Intellectual Property Right service, and the service tax demand was not sustainable.

Ratio Decidendi: A quality mark used for statutory certification and consumer protection does not become an intellectual property right merely because its use is regulated or unauthorized use is punishable; service tax under the Intellectual Property Right service entry applies only where a real intellectual property right is transferred or licensed.

---