Charitable registration under section 12AA cannot be refused merely for limited activity, incidental surplus, or possible future commercial receipts.

At the stage of registration under section 12AA, the authority must examine only whether the objects are charitable and whether the activities are genuine. Refusal cannot rest merely on limited present activity, incidental surplus, fees charged from members, or a of future commercial receipts from tournaments. Where the objects are to promote sport, provide coaching, and organise tournaments, and the material does not show any non-charitable object or lack of genuineness, registration cannot be denied. Commerciality, if relevant, is to be examined later at the assessment stage for exemption under sections 11 and 12. The refusal of registration was therefore unsustainable, and registration was held to be allowable.

---

---

Issues: Whether registration under section 12AA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 could be refused on the ground that the society had carried on only limited activities, earned surplus, charged fees from members, and might in future engage in commercially oriented tournament-related receipts.

Analysis: The objects of the society were to promote tennis and other sporting activities, provide coaching, and organise tournaments. At the stage of registration, the enquiry is confined to whether the objects are charitable and whether the activities are genuine. The absence of substantial activities, or the possibility of incidental surplus, is not by itself a valid ground to reject registration. The material relied upon by the Commissioner did not show that any object was non-charitable or that the activities already undertaken were not genuine. The position is supported by the settled principle that surplus arising incidentally does not destroy charitable character, and that commerciality, if any, is examined at the stage of assessment for exemption under sections 11 and 12. The CBDT circular also clarifies that cancellation or denial of registration is not mandatory merely because receipts cross the section 2(15) threshold in a particular year.

Conclusion: Refusal of registration under section 12AA was unsustainable and the assessee was entitled to registration.

Ratio Decidendi: At the stage of registration under section 12AA, the authority must restrict itself to the charitable nature of the objects and the genuineness of the activities, and cannot refuse registration merely because the society has not commenced substantial activity, has earned incidental surplus, or may later generate commercial receipts.

---