Printed product classification under Chapter 49 prevailed where identity and utility arose from printing, defeating the Revenue's Chapter 48 claim.

Printed sheets, leaflets and similar goods manufactured on job-work basis were treated as classifiable under Chapter 49 rather than Chapter 48 because the tariff entry and departmental clarification indicated that products deriving their identity and utility from printing fall within Chapter 49. The Tribunal also relied on the fact that the same goods had already been classified under Chapter 49 in the assessee's own case, and found no basis to depart from that view. The Revenue's challenge to the classification was therefore rejected, and the appellate order upholding Chapter 49 classification was sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether the finished products manufactured on job work basis were classifiable under Chapter 48 as contended by Revenue or under Chapter 49 as held by the assessee, and whether the Revenue's appeal against the classification order called for interference.

Analysis: The basis of the show-cause notice was that the products fell under Chapter 48, but the later clarification by the Chief Commissioner, relying on the Board's Circular No. 11/91-CX.4 dated 15.10.1991, stated that printed sheets, leaflets and similar matter used for a specified purpose are covered by Chapter 49 and not by Chapter 48. The records also showed that the same goods had already been held classifiable under Chapter 49 in the assessee's own case, and the Tribunal found no reason to depart from that view.

Conclusion: The goods were classifiable under Chapter 49 and not Chapter 48. The impugned appellate order was upheld and the Revenue's appeals failed.

Final Conclusion: The classification dispute was decided in favour of the assessee, with the Revenue's challenge rejected and consequential reliefs left to follow in accordance with law.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the departmental clarification and the applicable tariff scheme show that the printed product derives its identity and utility from printing and is covered by Chapter 49, a contrary demand based on Chapter 48 cannot be sustained.

---