Sovereign security functions are not taxable as Security Agency Service when performed by a public authority within statutory duties.

Services performed by a police department in discharge of statutory and sovereign security functions are not treated as taxable Security Agency Service merely because charges are recovered. The applicable service tax circular for public authorities distinguishes statutory functions from taxable services, and tax applies only where the activity is outside the statutory function and is rendered for consideration as a taxable service. On the facts described, providing security and related verification services was characterised as part of the police department's sovereign role in maintaining security, so the service tax demand was unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the police department's activity of providing security and related services for consideration constituted taxable Security Agency Service under the Finance Act, 1994, or whether it was a sovereign and statutory function exempt from service tax.

Analysis: The appeal arose from a demand raised on the premise that the police department fell within the definition of Security Agency and rendered taxable services by supplying police personnel for security and verification purposes. The decisive consideration was whether the impugned activity was a statutory duty performed by a public authority in discharge of sovereign functions. The service tax circular applicable to public authorities clarified that where an activity is a statutory function and the amount collected is in the nature of a statutory levy, service tax does not apply; taxability arises only when the activity is not a statutory function and is undertaken for consideration as a taxable service. On the facts, the service provided by the police department was treated as part of its sovereign function of maintaining security.

Conclusion: The activity was held not taxable under Security Agency Service, and the demand was unsustainable.

Ratio Decidendi: Services performed by a sovereign or public authority as part of statutory duties are not liable to service tax merely because charges are recovered, unless the activity is outside the statutory function and answers the definition of a taxable service.

---