De-oiled Rice Bran Taxability Turns on Same-Commodity Test Under the Assam VAT Schedule

Rice bran was specifically excluded from the exemption schedule and placed in the taxable schedule under the Assam Value Added Tax Act, 2003, so the controlling issue was whether de-oiled rice bran was a distinct commodity. The Court treated de-oiled rice bran as the same commodity as rice bran, relying on prior authority that it is only rice bran in another form without material change in composition. The exemption for cattle feed therefore did not apply, and the commodity remained taxable under the Act. The contrary Karnataka ruling was distinguished on the basis of a different statutory entry structure.

---

---

Issues: Whether de-oiled rice bran is the same commodity as rice bran and, therefore, taxable under the Assam Value Added Tax Act, 2003 rather than covered by the exemption entry for cattle feed.

Analysis: The exemption under Section 9(1) read with Entry 3 of the First Schedule excludes rice bran from the exempted category, while Section 10(1)(a) read with Entry 34 of Part-A of the Second Schedule specifically places rice bran among taxable goods. On a conjoint reading of the schedules, the decisive question was whether rice bran and de-oiled rice bran are distinct products. The Court accepted the view that they are one and the same commodity, relying on prior authorities that had held that de-oiled rice bran is merely rice bran in another form and that no material change in composition occurs. The Karnataka decision relied upon by the petitioner was held distinguishable because it dealt with a different statutory entry structure and did not decide that de-oiled rice bran and rice bran are different products.

Conclusion: De-oiled rice bran was held to be rice bran and, therefore, taxable under the Act and not exempt as cattle feed.

Final Conclusion: The revisions failed because the disputed commodity fell within the taxable entry and outside the claimed exemption.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the statute specifically excludes rice bran from the exemption schedule and includes it in the taxable schedule, de-oiled rice bran, being the same commodity as rice bran, is liable to tax.

---