CBDT monetary threshold instructions governed maintainability; later notional tax effect guidance did not apply to an earlier appeal.

A loss assessment with nil net tax effect raised the question whether the Department's appeal was maintainable under CBDT monetary threshold instructions. The Tribunal treated the earlier instructions as governing and found the appeal non-maintainable because the tax effect was below the prescribed limit. The later CBDT instruction on notional tax effect in loss cases was held applicable only to appeals filed on or after 15 May 2008, so it did not govern an appeal filed in 2005 and decided in 2007. The operative position was that the earlier instructions controlled and the departmental appeal remained non-maintainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Revenue's appeal was not maintainable for want of tax effect, and whether the later CBDT instruction applying notional tax effect in loss cases governed an appeal filed before its issuance.

Analysis: The dispute arose from a loss assessment where the net tax effect was nil. The Tribunal had dismissed the Department's appeal as non-maintainable in view of the earlier CBDT instructions limiting departmental appeals where the tax effect was below the prescribed monetary threshold. The later instruction issued in 2008 regarding notional tax effect in loss cases was held to apply only to appeals filed on or after 15 May 2008. Since the Revenue's appeal had been filed in 2005 and decided in 2007, the later instruction had no application. The earlier instructions governed the matter, and on that basis the Department's appeal before the Tribunal was not maintainable.

Conclusion: The Revenue's appeal was correctly dismissed as non-maintainable, and the later instruction on notional tax effect did not apply to the pending appeal.

---