Investor in Shares: Capital Gains Tax, Stock Valuation, Appeal Decision

The Tribunal held that the assessee should be classified as an investor in shares, with gains from sales taxed as per capital gains rules. The direction to re-compute the opening stock value was overturned, stating it should be valued at cost. The appeal was partly allowed, and the decision was announced on 14th March 2017.

---

---

Issues Involved:
1. Classification of the assessee as a trader or investor in shares.
2. Re-computation of the value of opening stock.

Issue-Wise Detailed Analysis:

1. Classification of the Assessee as a Trader or Investor in Shares:

The primary issue in this case was whether the assessee should be classified as a trader or an investor in shares. The assessee was consistently dealing in shares till the assessment year 2001-02 as a trader and joined employment with Indusind Bank on 30-05-2000. Post this period, the assessee declared himself as an investor in shares. The Revenue had accepted this classification in subsequent years, except for the assessment year 2004-05, where the AO and CIT(A) treated the assessee as a trader and taxed the income under 'Profit and Gains of Business or Profession.'

The assessee argued that no borrowed funds were used for purchasing shares, and the shares were classified as investments in the balance sheet. The assessee also contended that the principles of consistency should be applied, as the Revenue had accepted his status as an investor in other years. The Tribunal observed that the assessee had undertaken transactions in purchase and sale of shares and had declared himself as an investor since joining Indusind Bank. The Tribunal found merit in the assessee's contention and held that the assessee is an investor in shares. Consequently, gains from the sale of shares held for more than 30 days but not more than twelve months should be treated as short-term capital gains, while gains from shares held for up to 30 days should be treated as business income.

2. Re-computation of the Value of Opening Stock:

The second issue was the direction by the CIT(A) to re-compute the value of the opening stock as on 01/04/2003 at cost or market price, whichever is lower. The assessee argued that the opening stock in a particular year is always the closing stock of the previous year and cannot be re-computed. The Tribunal agreed with the assessee, stating that the opening and closing stock of shares held as investments should be valued at cost, as done by the assessee, and not at cost or market value whichever is lower, as directed by the CIT(A).

Conclusion:

The Tribunal concluded that the assessee should be treated as an investor in shares, and the gains from the sale of shares should be taxed accordingly. The direction by the CIT(A) to re-compute the value of the opening stock was also overturned. The appeal filed by the assessee was partly allowed, and the order was pronounced in the open court on 14th March 2017.

---