Strict compliance with exemption notifications: button making machinery failed the leather-industry design test for customs benefit.

Exemption under Notification No. 21/2002-Cus. required the imported goods to be specifically designed for use in the leather industry or footwear industry. On the invoices and catalogue, the machinery was described as button making machinery for the textile industry, and the materials did not establish design for leather use; incidental use in leather garments was insufficient. The alternative claim under Item 25 of List 34 also failed because the goods were not shown to be button-hole machinery for leather articles. Strict compliance with the notification's description and conditions was therefore required, and the denial of exemption was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether the imported button making machinery was entitled to exemption under Notification No. 21/2002-Cus. as goods specified in List 34 designed for use in the leather industry or footwear industry.

Analysis: The exemption entry applied only to goods specified in List 34 that were designed for use in the leather industry or footwear industry. The materials on record, including the invoices and catalogue, described the goods as button making machinery and as machinery destined for the textile industry. The catalogue and invoices did not establish that the machines were designed for use in the leather industry. The argument that buttons could also be used for leather jackets or coats was only a possible incidental use and did not satisfy the statutory requirement that the goods themselves be designed for leather industry use. The alternative reliance on Item 25 of List 34 was also rejected because the machinery was not shown to be button-hole machinery designed for leather articles. Exemption notifications were held to require strict compliance with their description and conditions.

Conclusion: The machinery was not entitled to exemption under Notification No. 21/2002-Cus., and the denial of benefit was upheld against the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: An exemption under a notification restricted to goods designed for use in a specified industry can be claimed only when the imported goods are shown by reliable material to be so designed; incidental or possible use in that industry is insufficient.

---