Permanent establishment and business-profit attribution govern taxation of crane-renting operations in India under treaty and Section 44BB.

Crane-renting operations in India were treated as giving rise to a permanent establishment, and the attributable business profits were held taxable in India. The ruling proceeded on the applicant's acceptance of the Revenue's treaty and charging provisions, so the Indian operations were treated as income arising in India. For computation, the business profits attributable to the permanent establishment were to be assessed under the applicable statutory and treaty framework, including Section 44BB. The reference was disposed of on that agreed basis.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the applicant's crane-renting activities in India gave rise to taxable income in India and constituted a permanent establishment in India; (ii) how the applicant's total income was to be computed for the relevant assessment years.

Issue (i): Whether the applicant's crane-renting activities in India gave rise to taxable income in India and constituted a permanent establishment in India.

Analysis: The applicant accepted the Department's stand that the project operations in India constituted a permanent establishment under the treaty and that the income arising from those operations was chargeable in India. The ruling proceeded on that agreed position and treated the business profits attributable to the Indian operations as income arising in India.

Conclusion: Yes. The applicant had a permanent establishment in India and the income from the crane-renting activities was taxable in India.

Issue (ii): How the applicant's total income was to be computed for the relevant assessment years.

Analysis: The Department's response, which was accepted by the applicant, stated that the business profits attributable to the permanent establishment were to be assessed under the applicable statutory and treaty provisions and that Section 44BB governed computation of the business profits.

Conclusion: The total income was to be computed in accordance with the Department's stated basis, including application of Section 44BB.

Final Conclusion: Both questions were answered in line with the Revenue's position, and the application was closed accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the applicant accepts the Revenue's construction of the treaty and the Act, the Authority may dispose of the reference by ruling that the Indian operations constitute a permanent establishment and that the attributable business profits are taxable under the applicable charging and computation provisions.

---